The original lighthouse, built in 1824, was approximately 500 yards northeast of the current lighthouse. St. Augustine Lighthouse. The tower is the second lighthouse tower in St. Augustine, the first being lit officially by the American territorial government in May 1824 as Florida's first lighthouse. Still, skeptics might scoff at a ghostly story buried within all that maritime history. HISTORY: St. Augustine is the site of the oldest, permanent aid to navigation in North America. This lighthouse replaced wooden watchtowers that were built in the late 1500’s. Many lives have been lost in and around the area of the St. Augustine Lighthouse. During its 100 years of existence, many lives have been lost in or around the landmark’s grounds, leading us to believe that those who perished there never truly left. The original lighthouse, built by the Spanish in 1737, was constructed with a naturally occurring stone called coquina. Just don’t expect to rest in peace. True ghost stories have been documented about this location in popular television shows like Ghost Hunters, and various other types of media all throughout history. St. Augustine, Florida, the oldest city in the nation, is home to arguably the most haunted lighthouse in America. The haunted St Augustine Lighthouse in Florida opens every day at 9am and closes at 6pm, on average. The St. Augustine Light Station is a private-aid to navigation and an active, working lighthouse in St. Augustine, Florida.The current lighthouse stands at the north end of Anastasia Island and was built between 1871 and 1874. You can enjoy many tours, ghost tours, and a gift shop. Wrap up your dive into St. Augustine’s haunted history with a stay in Lily’s Room at St. Francis Inn. It is believed that they remain on the grounds today. If you are seeking spectacular haunted places to go, please call 904-829-0745 for more information. The St. Augustine Lighthouse has been featured on shows such as Ghost Hunters and is considered one of the most haunted of St. Augustine attractions. The Inn, dating back to 1791, is known for the storied affair and tragic end of its former residents. Due to the receding shoreline, it fell into the… Hladik said that in the St Augustine Lighthouse & Maritime Museum, haunting tales they tell at the St Augustine Lighthouse & Maritime Museum are all old and remarkable in nature, which is why people take much interest in order to learn more about the past as well as loves horror flicks. The current tower, which was built in 1874, rises to 165 feet above sea level. The St. Augustine Lighthouse sits on the north end of Anastasia Island in St. Augustine, Florida. St Augustine Lighthouse & Maritime Museum Haunted History. The St. Augustine Lighthouse is definitely considered one of the most popular locations when it comes to the most haunted areas of the city.